← All posts

The 1996 Redraft: The Greatest Draft of All Time?

1996 NBA redraft cover, Draft Time Machine

June 26, 1996. Continental Airlines Arena. A skinny kid from Georgetown named Allen Iverson goes first overall, kicks off a cultural revolution and absolutely nobody in that building has any idea they're about to witness the single most loaded draft class of the modern era walk across that stage. Three MVPs. Five Hall of Famers already inducted with more coming. Eleven All-Stars. Eight players who made All-NBA teams, the most of any draft class ever assembled. A Finals rivalry (Kobe vs. Iverson, 2001) baked in before either of them had played a single regular season game. This class is usually ranked second all-time behind 1984 (Jordan, Hakeem, Barkley, Stockton), and honestly on some days I'd argue it deserves the top spot. On a scale of "fun" to "an absolute war crime against opposing GMs," 1996 is a 9.5. The only thing keeping it from a perfect score is how badly some of these teams botched the board, genuine top-10 talents fell into the teens, a top-3 all-time defender went completely undrafted, and at least three franchises are still explaining themselves to their fanbases thirty years later. So let's fix it. DeLorean's warmed up. Let's go back to Jersey.

If you need a reminder of just how much talent walked across that stage, roll the tape:

The Real Draft: A Quick Recap

Here's what actually happened, for those of you who need the refresher (or weren't alive yet, which, rude). Philadelphia took Iverson first, which, fine, no notes, he won Rookie of the Year and an MVP. Toronto, an expansion team that didn't even exist a year earlier, took Marcus Camby second. Vancouver, the other expansion outfit, grabbed Shareef Abdur-Rahim third and actually nailed it. Milwaukee drafted Stephon Marbury fourth and immediately shipped him to Minnesota for Ray Allen, who Minnesota had just taken fifth, a same-night draft-night swap that still makes zero sense typed out loud. Boston took Antoine Walker sixth. The Clippers took Lorenzen Wright seventh. New Jersey got Kerry Kittles eighth. Then things get ugly: Samaki Walker at 9, Erick Dampier at 10, Todd Fuller at 11 (this one still keeps Warriors fans up at night), Vitaly Potapenko at 12. Charlotte took Kobe Bryant 13th and traded him to the Lakers for Vlade Divac before he'd even worn the uniform. Sacramento got Peja Stojakovic at 14. And Phoenix, bless them, actually got it right at 15 with Steve Nash. Undrafted entirely that night: a 6'9" defensive menace out of Virginia Union named Ben Wallace, who would go on to win four Defensive Player of the Year awards. Let that marinate.

Now let's rebuild the board the right way: best player who fits the need, weighted toward peak dominance but not sleeping on the guys who were still great a decade later.

Here's how our 1996 redraft board shakes out with the benefit of hindsight:

1. Philadelphia 76ers: Kobe Bryant, SG (Lower Merion HS)

Real pick: Allen Iverson

Look, Iverson was a legitimately great pick and this isn't a knock on him: MVP, four scoring titles, dragged a roster of role players to the 2001 Finals by himself. But Philly's actual need in 1996 was a foundational franchise cornerstone who could win at the highest level for two decades, and nobody in this class did that better than Kobe. Five championships, two Finals MVPs, a regular-season MVP, eighteen All-Star nods, fifteen All-NBA selections including eleven on the First Team, twelve All-Defensive teams. Iverson never won a title; Kobe won five and is a top-5 all-time scorer doing it. Philly had zero infrastructure in '96, and taking the guy whose game (and ego) was engineered to eventually demand and win championships is the move, even if it means Kobe never becomes a Laker and the entire 2000s NBA timeline gets rewritten.

2. Toronto Raptors: Steve Nash, PG (Santa Clara)

Real pick: Marcus Camby

Ok, ok, Nash over AI, I get it but before you lose it, hear me out. An expansion franchise trying to build an identity in a country that thinks basketball is a rumor takes the actual Canadian point guard who would go on to win back-to-back MVPs? The marketing department dines on this for a decade. Nash averaged double-digit assists multiple seasons, he led the league in assists five times, and ran the most beautiful offense basketball has ever seen (personally biased here as Nash is my GOAT). Camby was fine, a DPOY down the line, but a rim-running big was never going to sell tickets in a city that needed a homegrown face. What Rose is to Chicago Nash could become for the Raptors. Imagine Nash with Vince Carter (when he arrives a few years later, of course I gots to get Steve some toys) making the Raptors a national institution a decade earlier than they actually became one.

3. Vancouver Grizzlies: Allen Iverson, SG/PG (Georgetown)

Real pick: Shareef Abdur-Rahim

Abdur-Rahim was genuinely good value here in real life, an efficient 18-and-8 scorer for a franchise starved for anything, but an expansion team desperate for an identity and a reason for anyone outside of British Columbia to care needed a star, not a solid rotation piece. Iverson gives Vancouver box office: a scoring champion four times over, an MVP, a guy who turned crossovers into religious experiences. Does moving to Memphis still happen with Iverson as the face? Maybe not. Maybe the Grizzlies stay north of the border. That alone makes this worth it.

4. Milwaukee Bucks: Ray Allen, SG (UConn)

Real pick: Stephon Marbury (immediately traded for Ray Allen)

Why run the trade at all? The Bucks already wanted Ray Allen enough to flip the rights to Marbury for him on draft night, so just take him directly. Allen ended up being one of the great shooting guards of his generation: ten All-Star appearances, the all-time three-point record at his retirement, and two championships including the Ray Allen Shot in 2013. Milwaukee's need was a scoring wing to pair with Glenn Robinson, and Allen slots in immediately. Skip the trade, skip the "what did Milwaukee even get out of this" conversation that's dogged this pick for thirty years.

5. Minnesota Timberwolves: Ben Wallace, C/PF (Virginia Union, undrafted in reality)

Real pick: Ray Allen (immediately traded for Stephon Marbury)

This is the pick that should haunt every team that passed on Ben Wallace, and Minnesota has the best reason of anyone to make it. They already had a 20-year-old Kevin Garnett; put the most ferocious interior defender of his generation next to him and you've built a frontcourt that nobody scores on for a decade. Four Defensive Player of the Year awards, two rebounding titles, four All-Star nods, five All-Defensive First Teams, and a championship anchoring the 2004 Pistons. KG never had to guard the paint alone again. This is the correction the league owed him.

6. Boston Celtics (from Dallas): Jermaine O'Neal, PF/C (Eau Claire HS)

Real pick: Antoine Walker

Boston was a post-Reggie Lewis mess with nothing to lose by being patient, and patience is exactly what O'Neal needed. The universe already tried to correct this one: Portland let him sit on the bench for four years, Indiana traded for him in 2000, and he immediately became a six-time All-Star and three-time All-NBA big man, a legitimate two-way force at his peak. Give him those four years developing in green instead of stuck behind Portland's frontcourt, and the Celtics have their cornerstone big well before the Pierce era takes off.

7. LA Clippers: Peja Stojakovic, SF (PAOK, Greece)

Real pick: Lorenzen Wright

The mid-90s Clippers couldn't shoot, couldn't space the floor and couldn't score when it mattered, and Peja is the best pure shooter in this class not named Ray Allen. He stayed in Greece for two more seasons in real life, so this is a draft-and-stash, but what arrives in 1998 is a three-time All-Star, an All-NBA Second Team selection, a two-time Three-Point Contest champion and the NBA's leader in threes made in 2003-04. Lorenzen Wright had a fine 13-year career as a role player; Peja is a franchise's worth of spacing.

8. New Jersey Nets: Marcus Camby, C (UMass)

Real pick: Kerry Kittles

The Nets were bleeding points in the paint, and Camby is the fix: he never made an All-Star team, weirdly, but he won Defensive Player of the Year in 2007, led the league in blocks four times, and played seventeen seasons. Put him behind Jason Kidd when Kidd arrives in 2001 and those back-to-back Finals teams suddenly have an elite shot-blocker at the rim instead of a committee.

9. Dallas Mavericks (from Boston): Stephon Marbury, PG (Georgia Tech)

Real pick: Samaki Walker

Dallas traded Jason Kidd to Phoenix six months after this draft, so the Mavericks were about to need a point guard badly. Marbury is the best one left on the board: two All-Star selections, two All-NBA Third Teams, and better than 19 points and 7 assists a game for his career. His reputation reads more "what could've been" than "what was," but as a scorer and creator he was the real thing, and Samaki Walker bounced around the league as a journeyman big. Big swing in value at pick 9.

10. Indiana Pacers (from Denver): Shareef Abdur-Rahim, PF (California)

Real pick: Erick Dampier

Indiana was already a contender, and Abdur-Rahim is about as safe and productive as a forward in this class gets: 18.1 points and 7.5 rebounds for his career, an All-Star selection in his prime, a guy who was good literally every single season he played. He never got to play with a real supporting cast in Vancouver and Atlanta; drop him next to Reggie Miller and Rik Smits and he finally does. Dampier was a durable, useful center; Abdur-Rahim is a starting-calibre scorer from day one.

11. Golden State Warriors: Antoine Walker, PF/SF (Kentucky)

Real pick: Todd Fuller

Todd Fuller played 189 games total and shot under 40% from the field for his career. Golden State desperately needed a young engine in the post-Run TMC hangover, and Walker gave the real Celtics three All-Star seasons and 20-and-8 production almost immediately as a 20-year-old, then won a ring with Miami in 2006. He wasn't efficient, that man loved a bad three. How can we not bring up his famous line: Reporter: "Why do you shoot so many 3's?" Walker: "Because there are no 4's." But he was a legitimate building block, and at 11 he's a steal.

12. Cleveland Cavaliers (from Washington): Zydrunas Ilgauskas, C (Lithuania)

Real pick: Vitaly Potapenko

The real Cavs actually got this one right eventually, taking Ilgauskas eight picks later at 20, so let's just speed up the timeline and skip the Potapenko era entirely. Ilgauskas became a two-time All-Star and, at his retirement, Cleveland's all-time leader in rebounds and second only to LeBron in points, before following LeBron to Miami for one last run at a ring. Cleveland needed a legitimate center in '96; taking Z eight picks earlier just means more prime years in wine and gold.

13. Charlotte Hornets (traded to LA Lakers): Derek Fisher, PG (Arkansas-Little Rock)

Real pick: Kobe Bryant (traded for Vlade Divac)

With Kobe already gone to Philly at 1 in this universe, Charlotte takes the steadiest guard left on the board. Derek Fisher fell all the way to 24 in real life and still became a five-time NBA champion and the owner of the most clutch shot in playoff history (look up "0.4 seconds" if you need reminding). He never made an All-Star team, but eighteen seasons of winning-calibre basketball and title pedigree is exactly the kind of value that should not fall to the mid-20s.

14. Sacramento Kings: Kerry Kittles, SG (Villanova)

Real pick: Peja Stojakovic

With Peja already off the board to the Clippers, Sacramento's need on the wing gets filled by Kittles, who lands six spots from his real draft slot. He made the All-Rookie First Team and later started at shooting guard for New Jersey's two Finals teams before knee injuries sapped his athleticism; a perfectly sound value pick for a Kings team a few years away from its playoff peak.

15. Phoenix Suns: Erick Dampier, C (Mississippi State)

Real pick: Steve Nash

With Nash long gone to Toronto at 2 in this timeline, Phoenix, who genuinely lacked size on the real 1996 roster, takes the best remaining big man on the board. Dampier had a long, productive sixteen-year career, was a double-double threat in his best seasons with Golden State, and started at center for a Mavericks team that made the 2006 Finals. Not a superstar outcome, but a sound value pick and a real positional need addressed at the back of the lottery. Phoenix's Nash-less alternate timeline is a lot less fun, admittedly, but somebody's got to take the L in a redraft this stacked.

Before we wrap up, Stephon Marbury has actually run this exercise himself, and his board is worth a look:

Final Thought

That's the thing about 1996: you can move nearly every star in the class to a different team and still end up with a defensible, need-based argument for the pick. That's what makes a draft class truly great: it's not just that the talent was there, it's that there was enough of it to fix almost every team's biggest problem in one night, twice over. The real version of this draft turned into three separate Hall of Fame arcs and a rivalry that defined the 2000s anyway. The alternate version just spreads that generational wealth around a little more evenly, and leaves at least one all-time great defender no longer standing in a gym alone, wondering why his phone never rang on draft night.

What do you think?

0/600